Import concentration, four cases: Vietnam phones, Indonesia fuel, Thailand chips, Germany cars
If you want to sell into a country, the first number worth knowing is not the market size. It is how much of that market already comes from one supplier. A market dominated by a single origin is a price-taking market; a market split many ways is one where a new supplier is a normal, expected event.
Here are four 2023 import markets, pulled the same way: UN Comtrade public preview API, 6-digit HS, flow = imports, period = 2023. The market total is the Comtrade World row for that HS code - not a sum of the rows we happened to be able to name.
The four cases
Vietnam · HS 8517 - telephone sets, including smartphones. 2023 imports USD 9,268,979,100. Largest named supplier China 85.13%. Two largest named suppliers: 90.66%.
Indonesia · HS 2710 - petroleum oils, not crude. 2023 imports USD 20,280,017,418. Largest named supplier Singapore 49.12%. Two largest: 71.85%.
Thailand · HS 8542 - electronic integrated circuits. 2023 imports USD 19,588,059,644. Largest named supplier Japan 10.62%. Two largest: 20.75%.
Germany · HS 8703 - motor cars for the transport of persons. 2023 imports USD 79,987,230,966. Largest named supplier Czechia 10.03%. Two largest: 19.92%.
Same method, four very different structures.
Vietnam HS 8517: one supplier, and it is not close
China supplies USD 7,890,500,153 of Vietnam's USD 9,268,979,100 in telephone sets and smartphone-class apparatus - 85.13%. The next four named origins together are under 7%: Republic of Korea USD 512,692,110 (5.53%), Mexico USD 74,574,421 (0.80%), Japan USD 70,854,616 (0.76%), Thailand USD 47,847,472 (0.52%).
Read this as an assembly pipeline, not a consumer market. Vietnam exports phones; what it imports is the input side of that pipeline, and the input side is essentially one country. If you are selling into this chain, you are not competing with four suppliers - you are asking a buyer to break an 85% relationship.
Indonesia HS 2710: two neighbours, seven tenths of the market
Singapore USD 9,961,450,357 (49.12%) and Malaysia USD 4,609,405,751 (22.73%) together are 71.85% of Indonesia's refined petroleum imports. Republic of Korea USD 941,225,259 (4.64%), Saudi Arabia USD 844,285,101 (4.16%), China USD 681,487,581 (3.36%) follow.
Two things follow. First, refining capacity next door is the market. Second, the remaining ~28% is genuinely contestable - several suppliers share it - which is a different sales conversation than Vietnam's.
Thailand HS 8542: this is what a fragmented market looks like
Japan USD 2,081,098,547 (10.62%), China USD 1,983,461,083 (10.13%), Malaysia USD 1,481,442,451 (7.56%), Republic of Korea USD 1,430,131,356 (7.30%), Thailand itself USD 1,047,112,380 (5.35%).
The leader is barely above one tenth, and the fifth-largest origin is Thailand re-importing from itself. Nobody in this market can dictate terms, and switching is routine rather than exceptional. The total - USD 19,588,059,644 - is not a niche.
Germany HS 8703: the exporter also imports USD 80 billion of cars
Germany imported USD 79,987,230,966 of passenger cars in 2023. Where from? Czechia USD 8,022,816,336 (10.03%), Spain USD 7,912,186,109 (9.89%), Slovakia USD 6,825,172,785 (8.53%), Mexico USD 5,062,788,270 (6.33%), United Kingdom USD 4,703,728,300 (5.88%).
The top named supplier is a Central European plant cluster, not a low-cost country, and no named origin exceeds 11%. For a component or tooling supplier, that is the most inviting structure of the four: many qualified origins, none dominant, and a market roughly twice the size of the Thailand chip market.
What we will not tell you
Two of these four markets have a disclosure that matters more than the ranking.
In Thailand HS 8542, USD 8,495,517,371 - 43.37% of the total - sits in partner rows whose M49 names are not in our frozen name table. In Germany HS 8703 the same gap is USD 13,009,784,002, or 16.26%.
Those rows are real trade. We simply cannot name them without inventing a mapping, so we do not put them in the partner table, and we do not claim they are small.
That has a hard consequence: for Thailand and Germany this page cannot tell you who the largest supplier is. The unnamed remainder in each case is larger than the largest partner we can name, so a single unnamed origin could well be at the top. What the table shows is the largest *named* suppliers - which is a weaker statement, and we label it that way rather than rounding it up into a ranking.
For Vietnam and Indonesia the gap is small enough (USD 454,734,233 = 4.91% for Vietnam, USD 1,188,247,837 = 5.86% for Indonesia) that the named leader must be the leader: China's USD 7.89 billion and Singapore's USD 9.96 billion both exceed the entire unnamed remainder.
This is the part of the work that is easy to skip. A concentration table that silently drops 43% of a market and then names a "largest supplier" is not a data problem, it is a false statement - and it is exactly the kind of number that gets forwarded to a boss.
How to read the four cases together
- 85.13% (Vietnam phones) - relationship market. You need a specific reason for a buyer to meet you, because the incumbent *is* the pipeline.
- 49.12% (Indonesia fuel) - two-supplier market with a contestable tail. The pitch is "the other 28%".
- 10.62% (Thailand chips) - multi-source market, and the named leader is only a tenth. You are a normal alternative; qualify on price and lead time.
- 10.03% (Germany cars) - fragmented at the top, and the unnamed remainder is large enough to reorder the table.
The cheapest form of market research is one number pulled from a public API. The second cheapest is knowing when that number cannot bear the claim you want to make with it.
Reproducing and extending this
Each case is a full pack - one country, one HS code, every figure carrying its source URL, retrieval date and the exact API query:
- Vietnam HS 8517 - telephone sets
- Indonesia HS 2710 - petroleum oils
- Thailand HS 8542 - integrated circuits
- Germany HS 8703 - motor cars
Free samples, no signup: Vietnam HS 8517 (XLSX) · Indonesia HS 2710 (XLSX) · Thailand HS 8542 (XLSX) · Germany HS 8703 (XLSX)
Want a different country or HS code? Verified trade data packs - USD 29 for the latest year, USD 49 for three years, USD 89 for five.
What we do not claim, in one place
Comtrade reports country-to-country flows, not companies - a pack tells you which origins supply a market, never which firms. Partner rows that arrive without a usable name are not guessed at; each pack's Sources and gaps sheet lists the exact residual and why. The market total is the Comtrade World row, so it is not understated by that gap. If a figure was not obtainable it is marked not available - we never fill a gap with an estimate. And a concentration figure is a starting hypothesis, not a conclusion: 85.13% does not tell you whether the relationship is contractual, logistical or tariff-driven, only that it exists, and that you should find out before you spend money on outreach.
Need this data as a spreadsheet you can check line by line?
Verified trade data packs — every figure carries its source URL →